Letters from a Catholic Feminist

Letters from a Catholic Feminist

Share this post

Letters from a Catholic Feminist
Letters from a Catholic Feminist
But What If Your Gut Is Wrong?

But What If Your Gut Is Wrong?

the joy of being proven incorrect

Claire the Catholic Feminist's avatar
Claire the Catholic Feminist
Apr 09, 2024
∙ Paid
27

Share this post

Letters from a Catholic Feminist
Letters from a Catholic Feminist
But What If Your Gut Is Wrong?
20
8
Share

Every woman I know has a story of intuition.

A story of a first date where you had a clenching feeling in your stomach, even though you couldn’t pinpoint why. A story of a time when you felt the sudden need to check in on your kids, even though everything seemed all right at the time. A story of a friendship that simply felt off, and when things came to light, you found yourself wishing you’d cut ties sooner.

A story where their intuition was a gift, and their body kept the score.

What is intuition?

Read more: Cold, Hard Proof of John Paul 2’s ‘Feminine Genius’

There’s quite a bit of (warring) science I won’t dive into here, but one of the gifts of the feminine genius is that women have a strong intuition. We have sensations that lead us towards action, even if they’re hard to define or describe. This often looks like someone saying “It was a gut feeling” or “I don’t know how I know, I just know.” Call it a hunch, or a vibe, or a hankering.

Your intuition is not some woo-woo manifestation magic; it has nothing to do with crystals or the full moon. What it is is a gift: a gift of your femininity, empowered by the Holy Spirit. Our culture often prizes cold, hard data over the beauty of a woman’s intuition, leading women to question themselves, ignore important red flags, and disown the feminine genius within them in order to lean into a more masculine, data-driven way of seeing the world. The prolonged effort to convince women they must be misreading situations can have a serious gaslighting effect, and can lead to women shutting down or ignoring their intuition all together.

So when women say to “listen to your gut”, or “follow your heart”, I think what they’re often trying to say is trust your intuition.

But here’s a question I do think we need to be asking:

What if your gut is wrong?

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Claire Swinarski
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share