Letters from a Catholic Feminist

Letters from a Catholic Feminist

Share this post

Letters from a Catholic Feminist
Letters from a Catholic Feminist
The New Prosperity Gospel

The New Prosperity Gospel

Our Lady of Lourdes, pray for us in our #healingeras

Claire the Catholic Feminist's avatar
Claire the Catholic Feminist
Feb 11, 2025
∙ Paid
58

Share this post

Letters from a Catholic Feminist
Letters from a Catholic Feminist
The New Prosperity Gospel
8
2
Share

This photo was taken in 2021. I was dashing from an early morning breakfast to the grotto at Lourdes, where our group of pilgrims was going to celebrate Mass at sunrise on our last morning together. Claire, my friend Shannon called. She’s the greatest insta-friend I have, always looking for that shot that will look #aesthetic in a square. I turned, and grinned, and it produced this photo. I love it. It’s not a flattering pose and I’m absolutely freezing in my bare legs but I was so happy to be there, at Lourdes. You can tell, I think.

I came to Lourdes with a specific intention, as so many do. A problem I had taken to the Lord over and over again. I was determined to be the widow who wouldn’t stop banging on the door.1 The magic water, I had heard, could heal anything.

The air outside was cold and sharp; the sun peaked out from behind mountaintops and the leaves were drifting down from trees in shades of amber and gold. But as I stood there and a French woman poured water into my hands, I felt nothing. I experienced no change. This problem was not fixed. This brand of magic didn’t work on me. Out of the thousands of people who’ve made pilgrimage to Lourdes clutching walking sticks and wishes, the church has validated 70 miracles.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Claire Swinarski
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share